
Cooperative Extension Service
P.O. Box 391,
Little Rock, AR 72203
Telephone: (501) 671-2000 Fax: 671-2251
University of Arkansas, Division of Agriculture and USDA Cooperating
ARKANSAS PESTICIDE NEWS EDITORS
Robert Frans and Diana Horton, Department of Agronomy, Fayetteville and Ples Spradley, Coop. Extension Service, Little Rock
Volume 4, June, 1994
How Are We Doing?
This will be the fourth issue of Arkansas
Pesticide News since we "re-started" in late
1993. In that issue, we said that we wanted to
keep you, the reader, up-to-date on pesticide
issues, such as registrations, cancellations,
and other issues. The three of us are heavily
involved with these issues for the Division of
Agriculture of the University of Arkansas.
Frans is the Arkansas State Liaison
Representative for the Pesticide Impact
Assessment Program (PIAP), which
coordinates the nations' state experiment
station and extension activities with agencies
of USDA and EPA. Spradley coordinates
pesticide assessment and other activites
concerning pesticides for the Arkansas
Cooperative Extension Service. Horton is
responsible for drawing together items of
interest for this newsletter, and for keeping up
with other activities relating to PIAP. There is
a regional flavor to our work - we meet
annually with like representatives from the
Southern states and Puerto Rico to report on
our activities and to discuss issues of a
regional nature. Our next meeting will be in
July in Roanoke, Virginia.
So -- how are we doing? We would like
to hear from any of you concerning the
newsletter. We hope we are providing you
with a useful synopsis of pesticide news - the
"good, the bad, and the ugly." Above all, we
will try to be factual and timely. We are
aiming for an issue approximately every two
months. If you see room for improvement, or
would like to provide us with sources of
information we might not have, please let us
know - our addresses are on the masthead.
Bob Frans
Ples Spradley
Diana Horton
News From All Over
No Yield Boost From Methanol
Spraying crops with methanol wood
alcohol did not boost yields in ARS scientists'
preliminary field and greenhouse tests. No yield
effects were seen by scientists who ran tests in
1993 at 14 locations mostly in the West and
South on cotton, wheat, and a dozen other
crops. John Radin, USDA-ARS National Program Staff, Beltsville, Maryland; (301)504-6233.
Why Save Our Endangered Species?
Scientists estimate that between 5 million
and 30 million species are living on the earth,
only a fraction of which have been identified.
They present several reasons for an all-out effort
to prevent extinction of these species. Medicinal Agricultural Ecological Aesthetic Arkansas Treefrogs
Spread Weed Disease
In southern Arkansas, green treefrogs has
been found to efficiently disperse the causal
agent of anthracnose of northern jointvetch, a
weed troublesome in rice. Until research was
started by X.B. Yang and D.O. TeBeest in the
Department of Plant Pathology at the University
of Arkansas, no one had noticed the value of the
small amphibians.
The particular species studied is Hyla
cinerea Schneider, which is distributed from
Louisiana to southern Illinois and commonly
observed in rice and soybean fields in
Mississippi River Delta states.
Chlorinated Pesticides
May Pose Cancer Risk
Dr. Leon Bradlow of the Strang Cornell
Cancer Research Laboratory, said his study into
the effects of chlorinated pesticides suggested
a risk promoting metabolic shift. "Our data
shows a wide variety of pesticides have an
effect on estrogen metabolism in a direction
increasing cancer risk." Kenneth Setchell said
that isoflavins present in soy products could
benefit women by increasing the time between
menstrual cycles, thus lowering estrogen production. But the question of soy's benefit is not
so clear cut, as isoflavin has both estrogenic
properties and anti-estrogenic behavior, said
Setchell. David Feldman, Stanford University
School of Medicine, offered a look at estrogens
in unexpected places, such as plastic containers. "Polycarbonate or related plastics in consumer
applications, although unlikely to be
hazardous, may require closer scrutiny, " said
Feldman. "Does (estrogen) metabolize or accumulate? We just don't know."
Pesticide and
Toxic Chemicals New, Vol. 22, No. 12, January
19, 1994.
The Pesticide Reduction Agenda
A "Broad Food Safety Initiative" (this description courtesy of the Agricultural Council of
America, or ACA) is being proposed by the
Environmental Protection Agency, the Food and
Drug Administration, and the USDA. The initiative as envisioned will reduce the use of pesticides
and promote sustainable agriculture. It
involves a comprehensive pesticide reform
plan, based more strongly on health, as opposed
to yields, using the negligible risk tolerance
standard for pesticides in processed foods.
Changes proposed in the pesticide registration
process would allow greater flexibility in getting
safer pesticides to the market. Other changes
would alleviate lengthy review processes when
health concerns are raised.
The Administration's proposal sets a target of developing and
implementing IPM programs for 75% of total
crop acreage by the 21st Century.
Regarding the initiative, EPA's
Administrator, Carol Browner, USDA's Deputy
Secretary Richard Rominger, and FDA's Commissioner Dr. David Kessler, say, "We want to
strengthen existing statutory authorities governing pesticides. Second, we pledge to upgrade
the science related to pesticides and food safety
especially as it applies to the protection of
children. Third, we are reorienting our efforts to
focus on preventing problems at the source,
through appropriate reduction of pesticide use."
They propose that any new statute establishing
tolerances should look at the likelihood of multiple exposures. For example, EPA would look at
exposure to a pesticide on lawns, in homes, in
drinking water, and in other foods.
Under the new proposal, EPA would be
required to complete review, within seven years
of enactment, of all existing tolerances to be
sure that they meet the safety standard. "The
burden is on the tolerance sponsor to show that
the statutory standard is met." If EPA determines the burden has not been met, the tolerances
would expire and complementary FIFRA
cancellations would be triggered without further
analysis or proceedings. EPA plans to speed approval of pesticides
it considers safer than those currently marketed.
Promoting IPM (integrated pest management) is
another aspect of this package. The administrators support a provision authorizing the
establishment of several pilot ecosystem based
reduced-use programs tailored to specific regions and involving growers, homeowners,
government officials, industry and others. WPS Implementation Date to be
Postponed from 4/15/94 to 1/1/95
Compliance with certain parts of the Worker
Protection Standard (WPS) has been postponed
from April 15, 1994 until January 1, 1995. The
extension of the compliance dates affects the
so-called generic provisions of the standard
which include training, emergency assistance,
information at a central location, and decontamination sites. WPS-related items that appear on
the label such as personal protective clothing,
restricted-entry intervals (REIs) and the requirement on some labels to post treated fields must
be followed when products with such statements
on the label are used.
The legislation also exempts the crop
advisor from the rule and it permits irrigation
workers whose feet, lower legs, hands and arms
are exposed to treated plants or soil to have
unlimited time in treated area during an REI.
They must, however, wait 4 hours after application or until ventilation criteria specified by the
label have been met, and they must be provided
and wear protective gloves and footwear and
coveralls during the REI. Currently, the rule
permits irrigation workers or any other early entry
worker who enters a treated field during an REI
and who has contact with treated soil and plants
to work only one hour out of 24. These exemptions for crop advisors and irrigation workers
expire on January 1, 1995. High Percentages of Commodities
Contain Pesticide Residues, USDA Says
At least one detectable pesticide was found
in nearly 89% of the apples, 85% of the
peaches, 81% or the celery, and 71% of the
potatoes tested under the U.S. Agricultural
Department's Pesticide Data Program (PDP),
USDA officials said last week.
Also, nearly 70% of the grapes, almost 60%
of the green beans, more than 57% of the
carrots and oranges, and almost 46% of the
grapefruit had at least one detectable residue.
The lowest percentages of residues were found
in bananas (37.1%), lettuce (35.6%), and
broccoli (35.3%).
Residues of 49 different pesticides were
found in 61.2% of the fruits and vegetables
tested. The levels generally were "substantially
below" tolerance levels.
DDT and its metabolites also were detected
despite a 22-year-old ban.
Although the pesticide companies have
said they are moving to a no pesticide level,
AMS Administrator Lon Hatamiya said more
than 60 pesticides were detected last year in
approximately 7,700 samples. Pesticide Container
Design Standards Do
Not Need Changes, EPA Told
Pesticide container design standards do not
need to be changed, the Texas Farm Bureau
said in comments on the container management
and disposal proposal. Also, Monsanto, Drexel
Chemical Company and FMC Corp. have asked
EPA to extend the comment deadline on the
proposal for 60 days, from May 12 to July 11.
The specific comments from the Texas
Farm Bureau included a recommendation not to
set field residue removal enforcement standards
because they "would be impractical to develop
and impossible to administer." The Bureau's
comments concluded:
"In regard to the finding that the cost of its
proposed rule would adversely affect small
for-hire aerial applicators, and that this cost
could be avoided by working from smaller,
nonbulk containers, we believe that
everything that can be done by EPA to
provide alternatives to those applicators
should be done in order to insulate those
applicators from the adverse effects of the
rule.
In regard to the cost to end users of
the rule, we believe that between $6 and
$9.9 million is not an unreasonable amount
of money. However, we strongly urge EPA
to keep the cost to the end user as low as
possible." Pesticide & Toxic Chemical News, April 13,
1994.
Benlate Contaminated with Sulfonylurea; Florida Charges DuPont
DuPont has been charged with selling an
adulterated and misbranded pesticide: Benlate
50 DF contaminated with sulfonylurea, the
Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer
Services said last week.
Bob Crawford, the department's
commissioner, said that department scientists
had confirmed the presence of dibutyl urea
(DBU), a breakdown product of Benlate that
poses immediate toxic effects to plants.
Sulfonylurea and DBU may be only two of the
toxic contaminant or byproducts of Benlate DF.
The Department said that sulfonylurea
herbicides are "100 times more toxic to plants
than any herbicide prior to 1982."
This investigation had the cooperation and
assistance of EPA.
NIOSH, meanwhile, has found the benomyl
metabolite MBC in soil, and in urine of surveyed
nursery workers. NIOSH found the metabolite in
soil at one of the study control sites where
Benlate had not been used since 1985. MBC
was also found in the soil of an investigation site
where Benlate had not been used since 1991. Agricultural Chemical News
April 15, 1994
OXYDEMETON-METHYL -- Miles -- EPA
has received a request from the manufacturer to
voluntarily cancel their registration for all their
products containing this active ingredient. (FR
Vol. 59, 3-11-94)
TEMIK 15G (aldicarb) -- Rhone Poulenc --
Added to their label the control of nematodes on
cotton.
FACET 50 WP (quinclorac) -- Label
changes for usage on rice include the addition of
Storm and blazer as a tank mix. It can also be
tank mixed with glyphosate for no-till and
reduced tillage rice production.
KARMEX DF (diuron) -- DuPont -- Due to
the high cost of re-registration, the company is
expected to delete the usage on oats and
bermudagrass from their label.
WHIP 360 (fenoxaprop-ethyl) -- Agr Evo --
Added to their label the tank mix with Reflex
2LC.
Farmworker Rule Implementation
Delay Specifics Noted by EPA
The impact of the farmworker rule
implementation delay bill signed by President
Clinton last week was explained by EPA, which
noted in a summary that the following are not
effective until Jan. 1, 1995.
An EPA communication to employees said
that the new delay law provides optional
personal protective equipment (PPE) require-
ments for some irrigation workers in 1994 and
excludes crop advisors from coverage until Jan.
1, 1995.
The agency emphasized that in 1994,
compliance with worker protection labeling is
required. These requirements include PPE and
restricted-entry interval (REI). EPA repeated
that April 21, 1994, is the deadline for label
changes and that products with new labels are
moving into the channels of trade. According to
the agency: "Between now and Oct. 23, 1995, products
with both old and new labels will be
available for sale. After Oct. 23, 1995,
pesticide dealers cannot sell or distribute
products without the WPS (worker
protection standard) label. Whatever label,
old or new, is on the product you use, you
must follow the instructions on that label.
When products with old and new labels are
combined, follow the more restrictive
worker protection requirements."
The agency said, "during 1994, there are no
time limitations to non-hand labor early entry.
Starting Jan. 1, 1995, early-entry work under this
exception is limited to short-term tasks and
usually not allowed to exceed one hour per
worker each day." "Irrigation workers who will contact treated
surfaces must wear the early-entry PPE
specified on the label. However, until Jan.
1, 1995, when there is contact with
pesticides only to feet, lower legs, hands
and arms, coveralls plus chemical-resistant
gloves and chemical-resistant footwear
may be substituted for the early-entry PPE
specified on the label. This provision for
substitute PPE will no longer be in effect
after Jan. 1, 1995". Handlers and workers already trained will not
have to be retrained under the new delay law,
EPA said, noting, however, that retraining is
required every five years. Under compliance
and non-compliance headings, EPA said: An agency official noted last week that irrigation
workers were likely to be handled under the
exception process being used for cut flowers
and ferns. California has filed a draft state
equivalency request covering display of/request
for application information, greenhouse
ventilation beyond WPS, but not the posting
sign, he said. Produce Group Blasts
EPA's Latest Delaney Clause Policy
A produce industry group last week blasted
EPA's latest Delaney clause policy halting action
on about 60 registration and tolerance actions
for pesticides which "induce cancer" in man or
animal. Specifically, the notice published in the
April 6 Federal Register stated: "EPA will temporarily stop all review and
processing work related to establishing a
registration and/or tolerance(s) for any
chemical/crop combination in which: United Fresh Fruit & Vegetable Association's
John Aguirre, Vice President, Government
Affairs, charged that "this action is the result of
an overly broad interpretation of the Delaney
clause and will delay or prevent the introduction
of many new and safe chemicals needed by our
industry. This decision will exacerbate the minor
crop problem and unnecessarily limit the ability
of growers to provide an abundant supply of
safe, fresh produce at reasonable prices." "EPA's recent announcement drives the
Delaney issue dead center into FIFRA,
where it doesn't belong. If the agency is
concerned over the prudent use of their
resources, they should start by addressing
the petition put forth by United and the
National Food Processors Association
(NFPA)."
The policy also covers Section 24(c) state
registrations. EPA's policy suggested that
petitioners separate tolerances affected and not
affected by the Delaney clause.
The policy, effective April 6, stated, EPA said that it has "determined that as
many as 50 existing food additive regulations for
pesticides may meet the induce-cancer standard
and will concentrate its resources on revoking
those affected regulations."
Pesticide & Toxic
Chemical News, April 13, 1994.
Granular Carbofuran Use Notice
Scheduled to Be Issued April 13
EPA's decision to allow use of granular
carbofuran on rice but not on corn and sorghum
is scheduled to be published in the Federal
Register April 13. The agency will allow 90 days
for comment. The notice said that the corn and sorghum
uses were being denied because there was no
new information or data filed that would
substantially change the previous risk/benefit
decision.
The rice use is being extended for two
years because there are no alternatives to
granular carbofuran, EPA said.
According to the EPA notice, "no production
and sales by FMC will be allowed for use on rice
during the 1996 growing season, however, if a
FIFRA Section 3 registration for an alternative to
control rice water weevil appears imminent at the
end of the 1995 growing season."
Also, the notice said, "FMC may be
required to implement label changes or other
measures to reduce avian risk during the period
of extension. These may include but are not
limited to: endangered species bulletins; user
education and stewardship programs, and
scouting to determine infestation levels prior to
application."
"The FWS (Fish and Wildlife Service) may
issue a new Biological Opinion during the
90-day comment period for this notice. The
opinion is the result of an ongoing
consultation between EPA and FWS
regarding the potential of carbofuran to
adversely affect endangered species. The
opinion or other comments from the FWS
could influence EPA's decision on
extending the use of granular carbofuran
on rice."
The notice offers priority registration
consideration to "safer" carbofuran alternatives
on rice. Restricted Entry Intervals (REIs)
by Monte P. Johnson
The period of time before anyone can enter
an area treated with a pesticide is called a
restricted-entry interval (REI). Previously, REIs
may have had the generic statement "until
sprays have dried or dusts have settled." This
statement may no longer be allowed on
agricultural pesticide labels. Instead, REIs will
be based on acute toxicity, eye irritation or skin
irritation effects of the active ingredients in the
product. In general, this will be indicated by the
signal words "DANGER/POISON, DANGER,
WARNING or CAUTION." REIs for single active
ingredient products will be as follows unless a
product-specific REI is longer: Toxicity Category I (Signal Word =
Danger/Poison, Danger): 48 hours. If the
active ingredient is an organophosphate
used in an area of 25 inches or less annual
rainfall (not including irrigation), the REI will
be 72 hours. All pesticide products
containing an organophosphate will
indicate this on the label.
Toxicity Category II (Signal Word =
Warning): 24 hours.
Toxicity Category III (Signal Word =
Caution): 12 hours.
If multiple active ingredients are in the pesticide
product tank mix, the REI will be based on the
active ingredient that requires the longest REI.
NOTE: Fumigants will retain the current REI
(hours, days or acceptable exposure level).
Agrichemical and Environmental News,
Washington State University, March, 1994.
Health-Effects Synergism Rare
in Pesticide Mixtures, SOT Told
A poster by a group of researchers from
Milan, Italy, presented at the annual meeting of
the Society of Toxicology indicates that fears of
synergistic effects from exposures to multiple
pesticides may be overblown.
Corrado L. Galli from the Laboratory of
Toxicology, University of Milan, said that there is
no general rule for predicting the effect of a
mixture, making testing necessary for each
combination. One goal in conducting the study,
he added, was to develop an in vitro system for
the rapid testing of such mixtures.
Another poster, by J.D. Farmer, et al., of
EPA's Health Effects Research Laboratory,
Research Triangle Park, NC, presented a similar
but much more limited conclusion based on a
study of the effect of a mixture of carbaryl and
triadimefon on rats. Carbaryl, it noted, had
previously been shown to decrease the motor
activity of rats, while triadimefon increased it.
When the two were co-administered, the study
stated, it was found that the carbaryl partially
blocked the activity increases produced by
triadimefon.
Sequential exposure to the pesticides
showed that treatment of rats and mice with
triadimefon three days before exposure to
carbaryl attenuated the decrease in activity
normally produced by the latter pesticide alone.
"These results," the poster concluded,
"indicate dynamic interactions between pesticide
exposures in their effects on neurobehavioral
function."
Pesticide & Toxic Chemical News,
March 23, 1994.
Organophosphates Deserve Own Risk/Benefit Evaluation, ACS Told
Organophosphates (OPs) differ in
chemical, biological and toxicological properties
and "deserve to be treated individually whenever
risk/benefit decisions must be done," Gunther
Voss, head of research and development for
Ciba-Geigy's plant protection division in Basel,
Switzerland, told an American Chemical Society
(ACS) meeting last week in San Diego, CA.
He criticized EPA's decision to treat
cholinesterase inhibition as an "adverse effect,"
commenting, "an enzyme whose effect is not
clear should not be used to penalize
cholinesterase inhibitors."
Voss reviewed a number of steps taken to
improve the benefit/risk ratio of various OPs,
including changes in formulation, such as micro-encapsulation; use of water-soluble bags to
reduce dermal exposure to solid insecticide
formulations; timing of spraying to "diminish the
effects of OPs on key beneficial insect species";
alternating or combining OPs with insecticides of
other classes and different modes of action to
reduce the risk of resistance development; and
educating the farmers, especially in developing
countries, on safer, more targeted application of
OPs. Pesticide Use on Vegetables
"Pesticide use is widespread in vegetable
production, according to new data from USDA's
Pesticide Data Program, which found that
growers use herbicides on 76% of acreage,
insecticides on 78% and fungicides on 56%.
The data show that herbicide use is highest for
processing vegetables and lowest for melons.
Nitrogen and phosphorus were applied to nearly
all vegetable acreage (96% and 89%,
respectively), while growth regulators and soil
fumigants were used less extensively than other
pesticides or fertilizers, with growers reporting
application to 17% of vegetable acreage.
"John M. Love, an agricultural economist
with USDA's Economic Research Service,
explained that pesticide use varies depending
on many factors, including the intended market
for the crop. Processing tomato production uses
more herbicides and fewer insecticides than
fresh-market tomato production, he said. Also,
methyl bromide is used on 61% of Florida's
fresh-market tomato production, while none is
used on California's processing tomato acreage.
Stating that chemical pesticides have been an
important input to production,' Love cautioned
that estimates of the impact on vegetable yields
from a substantial reduction in pesticide use are
likely to contain a high degree of uncertainty.
He called for more research in this area as
policies to change vegetable production
practices are debated.' Love stressed that the
vegetable industry's future productivity hinges
on continued access to chemical pest control or
alternatives." Maintaining Personal
Protective Equipment
"The new Worker Protection Standard has
created a heightened sense of awareness for
the need for personal protective equipment
(PPE). Personal protective equipment
represents a lifesaving as well as an economic
investment, and as such, deserves a great deal
of care."
"Clothing worn during pesticide use will
carry traces of pesticide on it, regardless of the
care taken by the applicator. Because of this
potential, all clothing worn during pesticide use
should be considered contaminated. Wash and
dry off the gloves and remove pesticide
contaminated clothing while still wearing the
gloves. Keep and wash pesticide
contaminated clothing separate from the
family laundry. Wash pesticide contaminated
clothing immediately after use; daily, if need be.
"Presoak or prerinse clothing prior to the
wash. During the wash, use hot water and
heavy-duty liquid detergent. Wash only a few
items at a time, using the highest water levels
and longest wash times. Don't throw those
clothes in the dryer -- line-dry them in the sun.
Sunlight helps break down many pesticide
residues, as well as drying your clothes. After
washing, run the empty washing machine
through a complete cycle with detergent to avoid
any possible cross-contamination with the family
laundry. Discard any clothing that is soaked or
heavily contaminated with pesticide.
"Liquid-proof PPE (coveralls, aprons,
raincoats, gloves, hats and boots) should be
rinsed after removal and washed with detergent
and water. Check gloves for holes by filling
them with water and squeezing. Check the
sweatband in your hat to make sure it is clean.
Wash boots inside and out after pesticide use
and allow them to dry.
"Respirators should be washed with
detergent and water and dried with a clean cloth.
If the respirator is a cartridge-type respirator,
remove and discard filters after each use. Store
respirators in a clean, dark place away from all
pesticides. A plastic ziplock bag works well to
keep dust and fumes out of the cartridges.
"Personal protective equipment is now the
law. Proper maintenance is only smart -- health-
wise, and economically. U.S. Food Supply Is Envy of World
Dr. Stan Schuman, a pediatrician and
teacher at the Medical University at Charleston,
and a liaison with the Clemson University
Extension service in an Agromedicine program,
is convinced that a balanced diet, including
ample amount of fresh fruits and vegetables, is
a primary reason for Americans' improved
health. The average life span of U.S. citizens
has improved steadily since the 1930s and rates
of gastric, intestinal and stomach cancers, as
well as birth defects, have declined significantly.
Schuman says that the National Academy of
Family Practitioners soundly endorsed the safety
of the U.S. food supply. The Environmental
Protection Agency and the U.S. Department of
Agriculture had made a call for more emphasis
on integrated pest management programs, a
philosophy that promotes judicious use of
agricultural chemicals. But, it has been difficult
for states to get funding for those programs.
A major breakthrough in preventing certain
birth defects, especially spina bifida and missing
brain, includes adding folate (found in leafy
vegetables) to the diets of pregnant women.
Schuman says no magic potion or formula
exists to prevent cancer. But lifestyle apparently
is a critical factor. According to Sir Richard Doll,
a British scientist, two-thirds of all cancers in
humans are preventable through a balanced
diet, adequate exercise and avoiding alcohol
and tobacco abuse. He emphasizes "abuse"
rather than abstinence. The other one-third of
human cancer is mostly a product of aging.
Fruits and vegetables also reduce the chance
for heart disease and promote longevity. The
good news is that in only one of six human
cancer patients is the disease fatal. Comments on the
1993 Arkansas Annual Report
Dennis D. Kopp from the USDA/Extension
Service commented that our program has
demonstrated strong working relationships with
state and federal agencies on regulatory and
pesticide issues. He also indicated that the PIAP
program has developed and maintained
cooperative relationships with the Water Quality,
Sustainable Agriculture, the Endangered
Species Protection Plan and the new Worker
Protection Standards Plan. He added that
through this program pesticide usage databases
have been developed, updated and maintained,
which address Pesticide Use Survey, Arkansas
Rice Pesticide Use Survey, Sweet Potatoes,
Cabbage, Green Beans, Cucumbers, Green
Peppers, Squash, Spinach, Apples, Blueberries,
Grapes, Peaches, Pecans, Strawberries, and
Watermelons. A comprehensive pesticide
usage database at the finger tips of State
scientists will be a very useful resource for
responding to numerous questions as well as for
research uses.
Ples Spradley contributed to the National
Pesticide Impact Assessment Program by
providing the leadership for a National
Assessment of Pest Management option for
Rice Production.
Dennis encouraged to include one or more
PIAP "Success Stories" in the Annual Report
where the PIA program made a real difference to
agriculture in the State.
Cancer Linked to Aging, Not Chemicals
Bruce Ames, a nationally prominent
professor of biochemistry at the University of
California at Berkeley, lectured on April 1 at
Washington State University about the relation-
ship between cancer, aging and the environ-
ment.
According to Ames, cancer incidence is
mostly related to age because each day, the
DNA in each cell is damaged up to 10,000
times. Our cells have mechanisms to repair
DNA damage, but these mechanisms are
imperfect because a majority of our bodies'
resources are devoted to reproduction and not to
maintenance. Thus, the number of unrepaired
and mutated DNA increases with time and is
thought to contribute to the incidence of cancer
and other age-related illness.
Synthetic pesticides, according to Ames,
represent little cancer risk to humans. Plants,
unlike animals, are immobile and do not have
the ability to flee a threat to their survival.
Therefore, plants are chemical factories that
produce many natural pesticides that protect
them from fungi, insects, and predators. Ames
estimated that 99.99% of the total pesticides we
ingest are natural and only 0.01% are synthetic.
Thus, too much of our nation's resources are
used in regulating pesticides and other synthetic
chemicals relative to the risks they pose in
causing cancer. The average daily intake of
DDT, a banned insecticide that has saved
millions of lives around the world by killing insect
vectors that spread diseases such as malaria,
has the same carcinogenic risk as drinking one
can of beer (a substance containing natural
carcinogens) every 8000 years.
Fruits and vegetables contain many
chemicals that are effective in reducing risk of
cancer to humans. For example, the chemicals
that make carrots orange (carotenoids) are
antioxidants and protect plants from excess
energy the plant receives from the sunlight.
Carotenoids, as antioxidants, reduce the amount
of oxidation and damage to our DNA, thus
protecting us from cancer. In a study in Japan,
smokers who increased their dietary intake of
vegetables reduced their risk of cancer by 50%.
The take home message from Bruce Ames'
lecture -- if you want to reduce your risk of
cancer, quit smoking, eat less fat and eat your
five servings of fruits and vegetables everyday --
just like your mother told you!
According to the U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service, at least 25% of all prescriptions
written annually in the U.S. contain chemicals
discovered in plants and animals.
Penicillin was developed from a fungus.
Taxol is taken from the bark of the Pacific yew
tree.
The heart medicine digitalis is derived
from the purple foxglove.
Thousands of plant species
constitute a giant reservoir of genetic material.
Scientists could plumb these to develop new
crops, improve the quality of existing crops, or
build in resistance to insects, diseases, and
other adversaries.
Individual species form an
ecosystem that purifies air and water as well as
provides food. A decline in population of a
species is a warning that environmental quality
is deteriorating.
Species and their ecosystems
form the foundation for a massive industry that
includes tourism, recreation, sightseeing, hunting, and fishing.
AG
Consultant, January 1994.
Chemically Speaking, March, 1994.
Pesticide & Toxic
Chemical News, April 20, 1994.
Pesticide & Toxic Chemical News, April 20,
1994.
It stated:
"Starting Jan. 1, 1995, early entry for
non-hand labor tasks -- including irrigation
work -- would be limited to one hour per
person each day if the entry would result in
contact with pesticide residues. The
agency currently is reviewing the
requirements and time limitations for early-entry irrigation work to identify situations
and practices where flexibility may be
allowed after 1994".
"Crop advisors are not covered by the
WPS until Jan. 1, 1995. The agency is
currently reviewing the requirements for crop
advisors, and may allow some flexibility after
Jan. 1, 1995."
"In general, states are responsible for
ensuring compliance and enforcement of
the WPS. In 1994, inspection programs will
focus on making sure that products have
new WPS labels, and on the investigation
of complaints and other high-risk situations.
EPA, the states, and others will continue
their efforts to help you understand the
WPS requirements and comply with them.
"If violations occur, states may take
action under state pesticide law or refer the
case to EPA. In general, if the violation is
minor, you may be warned the first time.
You also will be provided with guidance on
how to comply. For more serious violations
or repeated violations, you may be fined or
have other action taken against you."
Pesticide & Toxic Chemical
News, April 13, 1994.
(1)
either the chemical has been found to
induce cancer in man or animal or the
chemical has shown evidence of carcino-
genicity in animals or humans; and
(2) the
pesticide residue in or on a raw agricultural
commodity concentrates when the
commodity is processed or EPA otherwise
determines that a food additive regulation
is needed for the use. This will include any
work on registrations under FIFRA Section
3, experimental use permits under FIFRA
Section 5, associated tolerances under
Section 408 of the FFDCA (Federal Food,
Drug and Cosmetic Act), as well as food
additive regulation under Section 409 of the
FFDCA."
He concluded:
"Devoting substantial resources to petitions
raising Delaney clause issues will delay action
on the more routine actions. This is especially
the case where EPA has not yet resolved the
important policy issues relating to the inter-
relationship of Section 409 food additive
regulations and Section 408 tolerances and
FIFRA registrations, because actions taken
today might have to be revised if EPA policies
are altered. EPA will reexamine this policy once
it has resolved the policy issues raised by the
NFPA petition."
The notice continued
Pesticide & Toxic Chemical News, April
13, 1994.
Pesticide & Toxic Chemical News, March
23, 1994.
Pesticide & Toxic Chemical
News, March 21, 1994.
Pesticide Update,
Pesticide Section, North Carolina Department of
Agriculture 12(1), Winter 1994.
Food for
Life, 1993. SACA, P.O. Box 686, Dawson, GA
31742.
Agrichemical and
Environmental News, Washington State
University, April 1994.
bskulman@comp.uark.edu Briggs Skulman
Return to:
Agronomy
Homepage
University of Arkansas Homepage