Introduction to Philosophy: Overhead

Introduction to Philosophy	Notes	*This is not a substitute for coming to class - or for reading* the material.**	Richard Lee
Philosophy 2003 C 001	Notes	Copyright © 2002, Richard Lee	Autumn 2002

God Exists: Some Arguments

God exists: A circular argument

1. The Bible says God exists.
2. The Bible is the word of God.
I.e., If the Bible says x, then God says x.
3. God’s word is true.
I.e., If God says x, then, x.
4. What the Bible says is true. (from 2, 3)
I.e., If the Bible says x, then x. (by H.S.)
5. "God exists" is true. (from 1, 4)
I.e., God exists.

God exists: A valid argument

If Nixon was impeached, then God exists.
Nixon was impeached.
God exists.

God exists: A sound argument?

Either God exists or I am a monkey’s uncle.
I am not a monkey’s uncle.
God exists.

Richard Lee, rlee@uark.edu, last modified: 3 September 2002

	1.	The Bible says God exists.
	2.	The Bible is the word of God. I.e., If the Bible says x, then God says x.
	3.	God’s word is true. I.e., If God says x, then, x.
	4.	What the Bible says is true. (from 2, 3) I.e., If the Bible says x, then x. (by H.S.)
	5.	"God exists" is true. (from 1, 4) I.e., God exists.

	If Nixon was impeached, then God exists.
	Nixon was impeached.
	God exists.

	Either God exists or I am a monkey’s uncle.
	I am not a monkey’s uncle.
	God exists.